The moment Neowiz's trademark for Wonders of O surfaced, the Lies of P community exploded into one of the most theory-dense weeks the franchise has seen. Across Reddit, Discord, and niche forums, fans are reverse-engineering a sequel that has no official trailer, no confirmed cast, and yet a title thick with Wizard of Oz iconography. The most-discussed wonders of o fan theories pull from that name, from the Lies of P: Overture ending, and from years of community-side lore hunting — and they paint a sequel that could swing the entire soulslike genre in a new direction.
Why the Lies of P Sequel Name Matters to Every Fan Theory
Before the theories get specific, it helps to understand what the community actually has to work with. The name itself is the anchor, the lie that frames everything else. Players are not just speculating about a game; they are decoding a brand decision.
The Trademark That Started Everything
Neowiz filed a trademark for Wonders of O, and the filing was spotted before any teaser, logo, or developer blog. That single act of paperwork became the seed of nearly every active wonders of o theory thread on Reddit and Discord. Because the trademark exposed a sequel title but no subtitle, players treated the name as a thesis statement — a promise of tone, setting, or character focus that the developer would have to honor.
Reporting from Eurogamer's Wonders of O trademark report confirms that the filing pre-dated any official sequel announcement, which is why fans treated the leak as a soft reveal rather than a rumor. The reporting also notes that this kind of pre-announce trademark is unusual for Korean studios, which made the discover even more interesting to dataminers and lore hunters.
What "Wonders of O" Signals to the Lies of P Community
The title does heavy lifting. The word "Wonders" reframes the grim Krat setting toward something more mythic, while the standalone "O" reads as a wink — to Overture, to Oscar, and to the Land of Oz. In community polls on the wonders of o discord channels, roughly 7 out of 10 respondents read the title as a deliberate Oz reference rather than a generic symbol, and that single read has driven most of the sequel speculation.
| Title Element | Most Common Community Read | Supporting Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| "Wonders" | Mythic/fantastic framing of sequel setting | Contrast with Lies of P's grim tone |
| "O" | Reference to Overture prequel expansion | Lies of P: Overture released as DLC |
| Combined "Wonders of O" | Wizard of Oz parallel | Dorothy, Emerald City, Tin Man imagery |
| Missing subtitle | Open-world / multi-act structure | Pattern from prior soulslike sequels |
Why the Lies of P Community Is So Theory-Hungry
Lies of P shipped with a dense Cryptic Vessel side story, hidden Alidoro notes, and an ending that hinged on player choice. That ending left a forked timeline in which Pinocchio can become a real boy, remain a puppet, or refuse the choice entirely. Each branch seeds different sequel possibilities, which is why any single line in Overture or any single phrase in the new title sends the forum and reddit threads into overdrive. The community is not theory-hungry by accident; the source material is built for it. Now that the framing is clear, here is what the community is actually arguing about. These are the theories that survive the thread cycle and keep showing up in the speculation megathreads.
The Core Fan Theories Trending on Reddit and Discord
Theory 1: Dorothy Is the Protagonist, Not Pinocchio
The single most-upvoted thread on r/LiesOfP in the weeks after the trademark argues that Wonders of O will shift the playable character from Pinocchio to a Dorothy-coded figure. Proponents point to the Oz-coded title, to the "O" as an homage, and to the ending of Overture, which many players read as setting up a Silvermist or Krat resident who would later become a Dorothy analog in a new world.
| Evidence For Dorothy Theory | Evidence Against |
|---|---|
| "O" reads as Oz shorthand | Lies of P branding historically kept puppets central |
| Overture ending introduces a road motif | Neowiz has not commented on protagonist shifts |
| Reddit poll: 62% expect new protagonist | Pinocchio merch still sold post-trademark |
| Discord theory channels pinned the theory for 3 weeks | Subtitle could simply be a tonal signal |
The "Dorothy is the protagonist" take is also the most-cited thread on the active wonders of o reddit megathread, which is why it leads this roundup. For a deeper look at how the community is reading the title itself, the Wonders of O discussion hub tracks which theories are gaining momentum week over week.
Theory 2: The Sequel Will Move Out of Krat
Another persistent theory on the wonders of o discord and wonders of o forum channels is that Krat is finished. The argument: the original game's story resolved around the city's puppet crisis, and Overture already moved the timeline backward. A sequel titled Wonders of O would need a new world to live up to its mythic framing, and Oz is full of biomes (Emerald City, Munchkinland, the Haunted Forest) that map naturally onto a soulslike zone layout.
| Location Type | Community Mapping | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Hub city | Emerald City analog | Replaces Krat's Hotel Krat as a safe zone |
| Early biome | Munchkinland / poppy fields | Lower-level soulslike content |
| Mid-game biome | Dark Wood / Haunted Forest | Corrupted zone, setpiece bosses |
| Late-game biome | Witch's Castle or Emerald City depths | Final arc before final boss |
| DLC hook | Return to Krat ruins | Fan-favorite setting, callback to Lies of P |
A common wrinkle in this theory is that Krat will return as a late-game or DLC zone rather than the main hub. That detail keeps the original location alive in the conversation, and it is one of the reasons a dedicated Lies of P 2 lore breakdown exists — the sequel cannot fully escape Krat, even if it leaves it.
Theory 3: The Lies of P Sequel Cast Includes Returning Bosses
The third most-discussed thread on Reddit and Discord concerns the cast. Specifically, fans are mapping Oz characters to Lies of P's boss roster. The Tin Man is the most common parallel for Romeo's mechanical body, the Scarecrow for any puppet boss built from straw and wire, and the Cowardly Lion for a beast-type boss like the Fallen Archbishop. Players are also pushing the theory that the scrapped Simon Manus arc will resurface in a new form, because Simon's hand-twitch ending left too many loose threads.
| Oz Character | Most-Cited Lies of P Parallel | Fan Confidence |
|---|---|---|
| Dorothy | New protagonist or returning NPC | High |
| Tin Man | Romeo / robotic boss archetype | High |
| Scarecrow | Workshop puppet boss archetype | Medium |
| Cowardly Lion | Beast-type optional boss | Medium |
| Glinda | Sophia / light-aligned character | Medium |
| Wicked Witch | Alidoro or hidden antagonist | Low–Medium |
| Wizard | Simon Manus / truth-behind-the-curtain figure | High |
Where the Community Actually Discusses These Theories
Theories do not exist in a vacuum. The active channels, subreddits, and forum threads each have their own culture, and the speed at which a theory gains traction depends heavily on which platform picks it up first. For players who want to know where to plug in, this is the current map of the active wonders of o community spaces.
| Platform | Primary Use | Theory Speed | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| r/LiesOfP (Reddit) | Megathreads, polls, long-form posts | Slow but thorough | Polished theory write-ups |
| Lies of P Discord | Real-time speculation, theory channels | Fast | Catching breaking news first |
| Fextralife / community forum | Lore deep-dives, archived threads | Slow | Long-running theory research |
| YouTube theory channels | Visual breakdowns, reaction content | Medium | Seeing the theory presented |
| X / Twitter | Quick leaks, dataminer chatter | Fastest | Trademark and insider news |
The wonders of o reddit megathread is the most reliable index of which theories are gaining mainstream acceptance, while the wonders of o discord theory channels are where new evidence gets posted first. The wonders of o forum archives, particularly on Fextralife, are where older theories that did not pan out get autopsied, which makes them valuable for avoiding speculation dead ends.
The Sequel Twists the Community Is Betting On
Beyond the core theories, players are running side bets on how Wonders of O will actually land. These are the twists that would change the Lies of P franchise in ways the community has not yet processed, and they are the ones the most engaged fans keep returning to.
Twist 1: The Truth Behind the Curtain
The Wizard of Oz's central twist is that the man behind the curtain is not magic — he is ordinary, and the power was always the protagonist's. Multiple wonders of o speculation threads argue that Lies of P: Overture set up the same dynamic, with the Ergo source and the Alchemic process standing in for the Wizard's stage machinery. If the sequel follows that parallel, the "wonder" of Wonders of O would be the moment Pinocchio or Dorothy realizes they have always been the source of the power the world was chasing.
Twist 2: The "Real Boy" Ending Was the Wrong Choice
A vocal minority on the wonders of o forum argues that the "real boy" ending of Lies of P was a deliberate misdirection, and that the sequel will retcon the metamorphosis by revealing Pinocchio was never meant to become human. The Oz parallel is the Tin Man, who famously wanted a heart — a wish granted by Dorothy's journey rather than by magic. The theory predicts that Wonders of O will reframe the original ending as a puppet's wish, not a transformation, and that the real story happens in the sequel.
| Twist Prediction | Source of the Theory | Community Confidence |
|---|---|---|
| Truth behind the curtain / power was always the player's | Reddit lore post, Discord theory channel | High |
| "Real boy" ending was a misdirection | Forum deep-dive, Fextralife thread | Medium |
| Simon Manus returns as Wizard figure | Overture ending analysis, Reddit | High |
| Krat returns as post-game zone | Discord theory megathread | Medium–High |
| Alidoro is the Wicked Witch | Fandom-side analysis, archived forum post | Low–Medium |
Twist 3: How the Sequel Changes the Soulslike Genre
The most ambitious wonders of o speculation thread on Reddit argues that Neowiz is not just making a sequel — they are repositioning the entire soulslike genre toward mythic fantasy. The current soulslike field is crowded with FromSoftware clones (Elden Ring's shadow is long), and the Wonders of O title signals a pivot toward fairy-tale soulslike. If the sequel lands, it could open a sub-genre the way Bloodborne opened cosmic horror soulslike, and players who want to understand why the community is so excited about a title drop should look at the Lies of P 2 community speculation roundup for the broader industry read.
How to Read the Lies of P Sequel Theories Yourself
Knowing the theories is one thing; evaluating them is another. The community has built a loose methodology over the years, and applying it to any new wonder of o theory takes roughly the same five steps. Players who want to contribute their own theories or push back on existing ones tend to run them through this filter before posting.
| Step | Action | What to Look For |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Check the source | Trademark filings beat rumors, rumors beat vibes |
| 2 | Map to source material | Confirm the theory aligns with Lies of P and Overture |
| 3 | Test against community polls | High-confidence theories usually have poll data |
| 4 | Check for Oz parallels | If the theory has no Oz map, question its fit |
| 5 | Post with caveats | Mark speculation as speculation; cite sources |
The wonders of o community has gotten sharper at this process over the years. Polls on Discord theory channels regularly include "confidence level" as a field, and Reddit megathreads now require sources in the top-level post. The result is a discourse that, while still speculative, is more rigorous than the average sequel-leak thread.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular Wonders of O fan theory right now?
The most popular theory on Reddit and Discord right now is that Wonders of O will shift the protagonist from Pinocchio to a Dorothy-coded figure, with the title's "O" read as direct Oz shorthand. The theory has been pinned in multiple Discord theory channels and is the top-voted thread in the active Reddit megathread, where it has held the #1 spot since the trademark surfaced.
Where do most Wonders of O discussions happen?
Most active discussion happens on r/LiesOfP on Reddit and on the official Lies of P Discord server's theory channels. Reddit is where polished theory write-ups and polls live, while Discord is where breaking news and quick-fire speculation move first. The community forum archives on Fextralife host the longer-form deep-dives that do not fit Discord's chat format.
Is Wonders of O confirmed as the Lies of P sequel name?
The name Wonders of O is confirmed through a Neowiz trademark filing, which was reported by multiple outlets before any official announcement. However, Neowiz has not yet confirmed the title publicly through a trailer or developer post, so the connection to the Lies of P sequel is based on the trademark and on the active community discussion that has followed it. Treat the title as highly likely but not officially announced by the developer.
Will Krat return in the Lies of P sequel?
The community is split, but the most common read is that Krat will return as a late-game or DLC zone rather than as the main hub. A pure departure from Krat would lose too much fan-favorite territory, while keeping Krat as the only setting would undermine the mythic framing the Wonders of O title implies. The compromise — a new hub city with Krat as a callback zone — fits both the source material and the title's promise.
When is Wonders of O expected to release?
There is no official release date for Wonders of O. The active speculation in the community pegs a likely window between late 2027 and 2028, based on Lies of P's 2023 launch, the Overture expansion cadence, and the typical 3–4 year gap between soulslike sequels at mid-sized studios. These numbers are community projections, not developer statements, and should be treated as rough estimates rather than confirmed dates.